1991 All-State Teams
| FIRST TEAM | ||
|
POSITION
|
NAME
|
SCHOOL
|
| CATCHER | TIM PUNTILLO | ANDREAN |
| FIRST BASE | SHANNON STIGLEMAN | JAY COUNTY |
| SECOND BASE | KASEY CLEVENGER | MARION |
| SHORTSTOP | NEAL HARPER | FRANKTON |
| THIRD BASE | BRIAN GUZEK | HIGHLAND |
| OUTFIELDERS | JOHN CURL | LOGANSPORT |
| COURTNEY HALL | MCCUTHEON | |
| JASON PETERS | CULVER | |
| PITCHERS | BRIAN HOMMEL | PERRY MERIDIAN |
| RANDY COLLINS | LAPORTE | |
| CHRIS MOFFETT | SOUTHPORT | |
| GREG GRANGER | EDGEWOOD | |
| LATROY HAWKINS | GARY WEST | |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| CATCHER | MARTY HESCH | JOHN GLENN |
| FIRST BASE | CHAD KLEINE | MT. VERNON |
| SECOND BASE | ANDY HOEPPNER | WOODLAN |
| SHORTSTOP | TOM JOHNSTON | DECATUR CENTRAL |
| THIRD BASE | DUSTY ROBINSON | MCCUTCHEON |
| OUTFIELDERS | BRANDON MARTIN | NEW HAVEN |
| BRIAN DONAHUE | SCECINA | |
| RYAN SEIDL | JASPER | |
| PITCHERS | MATT HUMBLES | MADISON HEIGHTS |
| TOM BROWNING | NOBLESVILLE | |
| HONORABLE MENTION | ||
| GEORGE SAMONS | NORTHFIELD | |
| DAVE ROAHRIG | PLYMOUTH | |
| JON WIGGINS | EVANS. MEMORIAL | |
| RYAN FOX | PENDELTON HTS | |
| MIKE FETSCHER | EVANS. REITZ | |
| NEAL BOSTIC | CONNERSVILLE | |
| KEVIN PUTZ | S.B.WASHINGTON | |
| KEVIN BROWN | PIKE CENTRAL | |
| BRIAN CONNOR | BREBEUF | |
| BRIAN YEAGY | ALEXANDRIA | |
| HANK WHEELER | EVANS.NORTH | |
| MIKE WOLFF | SOUTH BEND CLAY | |
| PHIL TERRY | LAF. HARRISON | |
| NOEL SOVINSKI | TRITON CENTRAL | |
| TOBY JACOBS | SCECINA | |
| DAVE HILL | PORTAGE | |
| MIKE ANSERT | FLOYD CENTRAL | |
| ERIC HOPKINS | CRAWFORDVILLE | |
| JASON ROEDER | SEYMOUR | |
| BILL RILEY | CENTER GROVE | |
| BOB MCKEEMAN | MT. VERNON | |
| SHAWN LEMMONS | ANDREAN | |
| JEREMY TULLEY | WEST LAFAYETTE | |
| JASON BUERGER | FOREST PARK | |
| RYAN LONG | TWIN LAKES | |
| PHIL EISENTRAUT | NOBLESVILLE | |
| NICK WITTE | RICHMOND | |
| CHRIS ANDERSON | BEDFORD-N.L. | |
| STEVE DEVINE | FW. DWENGER | |
| BRIAN BISCHOFF | FRANKLIN COUNTY | |
| JEFF EBARB | PLAINFIELD | |
| SCOTT HENDERSON | HAUSER | |
| JOEL KINTER | NORTH HARRISON | |
| CHRIS FREY | NORTHRIDGE | |
| BILL JONES | SULLIVAN | |
| DARIN FARRIS | SPRINGS VALLEY |