1991 All-Star Teams
| Signed Before All-Star Game | School |
| Chris Maffett | Southport |
1991 North All Star Roster
|
PLAYERS NAME
|
SCHOOL
|
POSITION
|
| RANDY COLLINS | LAPORTE | PITCHER |
| JEFF BROOKS | HEBRON | PITCHER |
| GEORGE SAMONS | NORTHFIELD | PITCHER |
| MIKE WOLFF | SOUTH BEND CLAY | PITCHER |
| JOHN HUEMMERS | MISHAWAKA MARIAN | PITCHER |
| JAMIE SAILORS | FRONTIER | PITCHER |
| COREY NORRIS | HAMILTON | PITCHER |
| JODY BETLEY | F.W. CARROLL | PITCHER |
| ED BARNETTE | CROWN POINT | PITCHER |
| TIM PUNTILLO | ANDREAN | CATCHER |
| MARTY HESCH | JOHN GLENN | CATCHER |
| BRETT WINDMILLER | F.W. DWENGER | CATCHER |
| SHANNON STIGLEMAN | JAY COUNTY | INFIELD |
| JASON GOVERT | HOBART | INFIELD |
| KASEY CLEVENGER | MARION | INFIELD |
| ANDY HOEPPNER | WOODLAN | INFIELD |
| GARY COOPER | WABASH | INFIELD |
| JEREMY TULLEY | WEST LAFAYETTE | INFIELD |
| BRIAN GUZEK | HIGHLAND | INFIELD |
| ANDY PRUITT | LAFAYETTE JEFF | INFIELD |
| JOHN CURL | LOGANSPORT | OUTFIELD |
| COURTNEY HALL | McCUTCHEON | OUTFIELD |
| JASON PETERS | CULVER | OUTFIELD |
| BRANDON MARTIN | NEW HAVEN | OUTFIELD |
| STEVE CARTER | PENN | OUTFIELD |
| MEL WYSONG | MARION | COACH |
| DAN MILLER | HIGHLAND | COACH |
| LARRY CRABB | TWIN LAKES | COACH |
1991 South All Star Roster
|
PLAYERS NAME
|
SCHOOL
|
POSITION
|
| JASON RICE | NEW ALBANY | PITCHER |
| MATT HUMBLES | MADISON HEIGHTS | PITCHER |
| BRIAN HOMMEL | PERRY MERIDIAN | PITCHER |
| BEAU ADAMS | ZIONSVILLE | PITCHER |
| SCOTT JOYCE | FRANKLIN CENTRAL | PITCHER |
| JONATHAN WIGGINS | EVANS MEMORIAL | PITCHER |
| CORRY CORBIN | BARR-REEVE | PITCHER |
| BRIAN EVANS | TERRE HAUTE SOUTH | PITCHER |
| MALCOLM ABLE | NORTH HARRISON | PITCHER |
| BRIAN YEAGY | ALEXANDRIA | CATCHER |
| KEVIN BROWN | PIKE CENTRAL | CATCHER |
| HANK WHELLER | EVANS. NORTH | CATCHER |
| CHAD DECKER | PRINCETON | INFIELD |
| CHAD KLEINE | MT VERNON(Fortville) | INFIELD |
| JIM HILL | WEST VIGO | INFIELD |
| TOM JOHNSTON | DECATUR CENTRAL | INFIELD |
| NEIL HARPER | FRANKTON | INFIELD |
| BRIAN SIMMONS | RONCALLI | INFIELD |
| CLINT RAYMORE | PENDLETON HTS | INFIELD |
| VINCE PARSHALL | RICHMOND | INFIELD |
| CHRIS ANDERSON | BEDFORD N LAWRENCE | OUTFIELD |
| RYAN SEIDL | JASPER | OUTFIELD |
| PHIL EISENTRAUT | NOBLESVILLE | OUTFIELD |
| BRIAN BISCHOFF | FRANKLIN COUNTY | OUTFIELD |
| JEFF EBARB | PLAINFIELD | OUTFIELD |
| TERRY GOBERT | JASPER | COACH |
| BILL STOUDT | PENDLETON HTS | COACH |
| JOHN BUERGER | NEW ALBANY | COACH |
| HONORARY ALL-STAR DAVE MABRY BLOOMINGTON SOUTH (in Air Force Academy) |