2012 Academic All-State
| PLAYER | SCHOOL |
| Aaron Gegg | Covenant Christian |
| Adam Hufford | Guerin Catholic |
| Alex Benson | Lawrence North |
| Alex Brewers | Elkhart Memorial |
| Alex Hostetler | Penn |
| Alex Ocken | FW Canterbury |
| Andrew Adelsperger | Peru |
| Andrew Bradley | Clinton Central |
| Austin Boos | Cathedral |
| Austin Magley | Lowell |
| Brenden Popson | Our Lady of Providence |
| Caleb Baechtold | Bloomington South |
| Caleb Strubary | Whiting |
| Casey Demonia | Mishawaka |
| Chaise Kahlenbeck | FW Bishop Dwenger |
| Charlie Dreessen | John Glenn |
| Chris Eckersley | Park Tudor |
| Chris Slivka | Munster |
| Christian Vukas | McCutcheon |
| Clay Small | Fishers |
| Cody Gardner | Terre Haute North |
| Connor Brown | SB Saint Joseph |
| Connor Hale | Brebeuf Jesuit |
| Connor Kirtley | Seymour |
| Connor Reed | Columbia City |
| Craig Brainard | Crawfordsville |
| Craig Larew | Lawrence North |
| Dalton Lemert | Elkhart Christian |
| Dustin Wanner | South Adams |
| Eric Bennett | Brebeuf Jesuit |
| Ethan Gerardet | FW Canterbury |
| Evan Witsken | SB Saint Joseph |
| Greg Thome | Valparaiso |
| Hazen Hamather | Covenant Christian |
| Hunter Peppler | Angola |
| J P Pena | Fishers |
| Jackson O’Brien | Logansport |
| Jake Brown | Brownstown Central |
| Jake Willhite | Rising Sun |
| Jared Miller | Bethany Christian |
| Jered Wentz | Zionsville |
| Joe Dinkel | Lafayette Harrison |
| Jon Stewart | John Glenn |
| Jordan Crabb | Twin Lakes |
| Jordan Deal | Brownsburg |
| Joseph Bondi | Whiting |
| Kareem Itani | Zionsville |
| Kyle Potter | North Montgomery |
| Luke Polster | Highland |
| Luke Stephenson | Triton Central |
| Mark Smith | North Central |
| Mason Heller | Leo |
| Mason SChaller | Lebanon |
| Matthew Fox | South Central |
| Michael Moffatt | Lawrence Central |
| Michael Nichols | Noblesville |
| Michael Paisley | Brebeuf Jesuit |
| Mike Carnahan | Lafayette Harrison |
| Mike McBride | Westfield |
| Nevil Parikh | FW Canterbury |
| Nevin Fansher | Noblesville |
| Nick McCarty | Cathedral |
| Nick Thompson | Covenant Christian |
| Peter Lannoo | Terre Haute South |
| Peter Schrock | Bethany Christian |
| Preston Miller | Concord |
| Reif Haefner | Evansville Bosse |
| Ryan Frantz | Maconaquah |
| Ryan Lasley | Princeton |
| Sam Konkel | Lafayette Harrison |
| Scott Hoeppner | South Adams |
| Seth Huxford | Concord |
| Steven Durr | Sheridan |
| Tommy Knape | John Glenn |
| Tyler Cole | Munster |
| Tyler Ziliak | Gibson Southern |
| Vincent Williams | Center Grove |
| Wade Toppe | Brownstown Central |
| Warren Kay | Goshen |
| Will Bowman | Columbus North |