2009 Academic All-State
| PLAYER | SCHOOL |
| Zach Sherwood | Franklin Central |
| John Mullaney | Hammond Bishop Noll |
| Luke Claflin | Lawrence Central |
| Troy Dunn | Jay County |
| Reed Haines | Canterbury |
| Griffin Corn | Daleville |
| Eric Zeltwanger | Bremen |
| Trevor Yerrick | FW Bishop Dwenger |
| Kevin Nossem | Munster |
| Jared Van Winkle | Boonville |
| Ryan Kessens | Perry Central |
| John Brumleve | Bishop Chatard |
| Brian Hanley | Cardinal Ritter |
| Johnathan Martin | Center Grove |
| Josiah Gerardot | Canterbury |
| Jamon Hammel | Huntington North |
| Kevin Blessinger | Brownsburg |
| Cameron Spencer | Hobart |
| Adam Hendrickson | Boonville |
| Roger Sammon | Lake Central |
| Christopher Meyer | Batesville |
| Cory Kirkham | Zionsville |
| JoJo Dorenbusch | Columbus North |
| Patrick Veerkamp | Homestead |
| Jeremy Chesher | Jeffersonville |
| Jason Isch | Norwell |
| Cameron Metzger | Charlestown |
| Michael Ludwig | Brebeuf Jesuit |
| Nick Scheidler | Whiteland |
| Austin Hauser | Perry Central |
| Joe Wojda | Guerin Catholic |
| Adam Culiver | Castle |
| Zach Fields | Evansville North |
| Aury Keller | Woodlan |
| Jimmy Corcoran | Northwestern |
| Alex Juerling | Cathedral |
| Jacob Banitt | Fishers |
| Colin Holmes | fairfield |
| Andrew Graman | North Knox |
| Jacob Egan | Rensselear Central |
| Adam Schaffer | New Haven |
| Ryan Bolenbaugh | North Knox |
| Logan Schwerer | Whiteland |
| Kevin Wynn | Center Grove |
| CJ West | Rushville |
| Jack Dillon | Brebeuf Jesuit |
| Graham Saiko | Castle |
| Max Kitten | Forest Park |
| Jordan Robinson | North Central |
| Christian Rector | Heritage Christian |