2023 All-Star North and South Rosters
NORTH
| Adam Lehmann | Penn | Pitcher |
| Bryce Riggs | Noblesville | Pitcher |
| Cole Martz | Huntington North | Pitcher |
| Alec Hershberger | Fairfield | Pitcher |
| Richard Anglin | LaPorte | Pitcher |
| Christian Pownall | Western | Pitcher |
| Will Worrel | FW Carroll | Pitcher |
| Evan Cooke | West Lafayette | Pitcher |
| Garrett Benko | Andrean | Pitcher |
| Sebastian Salazar | Sheridan | Pitcher |
| Chase Long | Delphi | Catcher |
| Collin Lindsey | Westfield | Catcher |
| Mo Lloyd | Southwood | Catcher |
| John Curl | Kokomo | First Base |
| Mitchell Dean | Western | First Base |
| Hunter Snyder | Lake Central | Middle Infield |
| Bradyn Douglas | Frankton | Middle Infield |
| Tarick McGlothin | Rochester | Middle Infield |
| Cole Temple | Yorktown | Middle Infield |
| Luke Burford | Crown Point | Middle Infield |
| Josh Adamczewski | Lake Central | Third Base |
| Brycen Hannah | John Glenn | Third Base |
| Gavin Collins | Northridge | Outfield |
| Kevin Corcoran Jr. | Illiana Christian | Outfield |
| Zachary Stawski | SB St. Joseph | Outfield |
| Grady Kepplin | New Prairie | Outfield |
| Kaden Rose | Mishawaka | Outfield |
| Brody Zimmer | McCutcheon | Outfield |
| Dave Ginder | FW Carroll | Head Coach |
| Darin Kauffman | Fairfield | Asst. Coach |
| Michael Isaacs | Lakeland | Asst. Coach |
| Kevin Fitzgerald | Noblesville | Asst. Coach |
SOUTH
| Ty Bradle | Hamilton Southeastern | Pitcher |
| Mick Uebelhor | Southridge | Pitcher |
| Jacob Murphy | Center Grove | Pitcher |
| Ben Orrill | Madison | Pitcher |
| Cameron Tilly | Castle | Pitcher |
| Clayton Weisheit | Forest Park | Pitcher |
| Kyle Manship | Fishers | Pitcher |
| Noah Wathen | Floyd Central | Pitcher |
| Mason Tibbs | Brownsburg | Pitcher |
| Jake Hooker | University | Pitcher |
| Drew Bradley | Jasper | Catcher |
| Jake Dill | Cardinal Ritter | Catcher |
| Chance Bentley | Connersville | Catcher |
| Rylee Singleton | Evansville North | First Base |
| Charlie Baker | North Central | First Base |
| Jace Burton | Silver Creek | Middle Infield |
| Kyuss Gargett | Cathedral | Middle Infield |
| Brady Yeryar | Shakamak | Middle Infield |
| Carter Murphy | West Vigo | Middle Infield |
| Drew Culbertson | Center Grove | Middle Infield |
| Brett Sherrard | Bloomfield | Third Base |
| Charlie Shebler | Batesville | Third Base |
| Nate Simpson | Avon | Outfield |
| Max Clark | Franklin Community | Outfield |
| Andrew Wiggins | Heritage Christian | Outfield |
| Jaden Hart | Jeffersonville | Outfield |
| Owen Imel | Lapel | Outfield |
| Wes Stiller | New Palestine | Outfield |
| Casey LaDuke | Floyd Central | Head Coach |
| Culley DeGroote | West Vigo | Asst. Coach |
| Ryan Feyerabend | Franklin Community | Asst. Coach |
| Chris Hogan | Floyd Central | Asst. Coach |
| Jamie Polk | Floyd Central | Asst. Coach |